Guide to Diecast Collecting and Selling – Nascar to Musclecar

By Car Sales Guy • September 7th, 2009

Do You Love Collecting?

Would you like to make a business out of collecting diecast?

Thousands of people collect items of all sorts in this and many countries in the world. Some of the most passionate collectors or any item are collectors of NASCAR and Musclecar diecast cars.

These fans take collecting to the highest level spending thousands of dollars per year on their collections and the displays for these same collections. Therefore diecast collecting can be an attractive and fun business with a worldwide market potential and it is a worthwhile business to consider.

Making a living selling diecast can be problematic however.  The key to profitable diecast collecting can be elusive. There are too many variables in the business of collecting and then selling both NASCAR and MUSCLECAR diecast to make it a slam dunk money maker.

2000 Dale Earnhardt 3 Peter Max Hauler 1 64 NIB LE
2000 Dale Earnhardt 3 Peter Max Hauler 1 64 NIB LE
Paypal   US $34.79
Lot of 11 Action Elite 164 Diecast Cars
Lot of 11 Action Elite 164 Diecast Cars
Paypal   US $55.00
2002 Dale Earnhardt Jr 3 Nilla Wafer Nutter Butter NIB
2002 Dale Earnhardt Jr 3 Nilla Wafer Nutter Butter NIB
Paypal   US $49.99
2003 Dale Earnhardt Jr 8 MLB All Star Game Chicago NIB
2003 Dale Earnhardt Jr 8 MLB All Star Game Chicago NIB
Paypal   US $59.99
2002 Dale Earnhardt Jr 8 Ritz Oreo Diecast COA NIB
2002 Dale Earnhardt Jr 8 Ritz Oreo Diecast COA NIB
Paypal   US $89.99
2003 Tony Stewart 8 3 Doors Down Diecast AUTOGRAPHED
2003 Tony Stewart 8 3 Doors Down Diecast AUTOGRAPHED
Paypal   US $129.99
RARE LOT 18 DALE EARNHARDT ITEMS FROM ESTATE FIND NR
RARE LOT 18 DALE EARNHARDT ITEMS FROM ESTATE FIND NR
Paypal   US $52.63
Jeff Burton Hotwheels lot 30 cars treasure hunts etc
Jeff Burton Hotwheels lot 30 cars treasure hunts etc
Paypal   US $60.00
JEFF GORDON LOT OF 10 ACTION 1 64 DIECAST
JEFF GORDON LOT OF 10 ACTION 1 64 DIECAST
Paypal   US $29.99
2000 Dale Earnhardt 3 TAZ NO BULL Diecast LE NIB
2000 Dale Earnhardt 3 TAZ NO BULL Diecast LE NIB
Paypal   US $39.99
   1

Diecasts are COLLECTIBLE items. This usually means that they usually are only worth a premium to a specific collector. Almost every diecast made has a buyer, the trick is to have your diecast available when that particular buyer is looking for it. A very rare Dale Earnhardt Senior diecast listed in the various guides and collectible digests with a value in the hundreds of dollars may only bring a few dollars if it is listed incorrectly or at the wrong time.

[bonanzle:user:1 |cat:11|show:5|paginate:on]

In NASCAR, drivers, cars and sponsors change every year. The value of these corresponding diecast collectibles varies with these changes in circumstance.  One key to diecast collecting is to diversify your collection in a way that will broaden the exposure of any one driver or manufacturer, i.e. do not invest in only one or two baskets. Your driver could lose his ride, your specific diecast manufacturer could lose it's cache'.  Never bet on any one sure thing, you can never be that sure.

Jeff Burton Hotwheels lot 30 cars treasure hunts etc
Jeff Burton Hotwheels lot 30 cars treasure hunts etc
Paypal   US $60.00
RYAN NEWMAN signed 2010 US ARMY 1 24 ACTION
RYAN NEWMAN signed 2010 US ARMY 1 24 ACTION
Paypal   US $80.00
JOEY LOGANO signed 2009 NEW HAMPSIRE WIN 1 24 ACTION
JOEY LOGANO signed 2009 NEW HAMPSIRE WIN 1 24 ACTION
Paypal   US $80.00
2008 Ryan Newman Atlanta Win Truck Autograph 1 24
2008 Ryan Newman Atlanta Win Truck Autograph 1 24
Paypal   US $81.00
Wrigley’s Juicy Fruit Juan Pablo Montoya Autographed
Wrigley’s Juicy Fruit Juan Pablo Montoya Autographed
Paypal   US $147.00
2005 Kevin Harvick 29 GM DAYTONA 1 24 Action SIGNED
2005 Kevin Harvick 29 GM DAYTONA 1 24 Action SIGNED
Paypal   US $49.95
2001 Ryan Newman 02 FIRST BUSCH WIN Pref 1 24 SIGNED
2001 Ryan Newman 02 FIRST BUSCH WIN Pref 1 24 SIGNED
Paypal   US $99.95
Action 1 24 JLogano 25 Racing Oil 2008 Chevy Raced
Action 1 24 JLogano 25 Racing Oil 2008 Chevy Raced
Paypal   US $45.99
Tony Stewart 1999 Action 1 18 AUTOGRAPHED Diecast AUTO
Tony Stewart 1999 Action 1 18 AUTOGRAPHED Diecast AUTO
Paypal   US $59.99
RCCA 1 24 Harvick Driven to the Outdoors 2008 Chevy
RCCA 1 24 Harvick Driven to the Outdoors 2008 Chevy
Paypal   US $20.50
   1

The smart collector and the smarter seller knows to invest in many different types of diecast to maintain the value of the collection.

Diecast sellers must be willing to cut losses and move on, it is an essential attitude if you are planning on selling diecast.  Becoming attached to a particular car or driver and holding your perceived value for that car or drivers car higher than the market will bear is a sure sign that you will not be the most profitable in this business.

Other factors to consider when investing in a collection for resale

  • Manufacturer - All diecast manufactures are not created equal. Also, not all products from each manufacturer are high quality.  Diecast cars of all sorts purchased at big box retailers such as Walmart, Sam's Club, Kmart, Target etc are usually of the lowest quality and almost never considered as fine collectible diecasts.  Closeout deals can provide stocking stuffers or loss leaders for your sales but the pricing must be less than 50% of retail to make this type of closeout attractive to a diecast seller.
  • Rarity - Is the car you are considering easy or hard to find? The more rare a diecast is the better - usually.  You must have corroborating evidence that your "rare" diecast is actually valuable. A 1998 Steve Park Action Pennzoil GM Dealers Snap-On 1/24 1 of 459 issued diecast may be a rare car, but it also not a very valuable car. Keep in mind that some "rare" cars are simply unwanted. While other just have not yet found the light of day.  Be reasonable and know that a Dale Earnhardt car may be worth more than Steve Park.
  • Driver - In NASCAR the driver is almost everything. This rule does not apply always but it is a pretty good one to follow.  Keep in mind the history of NASCAR and know that drivers change teams and sponsors and they also sometimes rise and fall in popularity.  Dale Earnhardt Jr. is a perpetual fan favorite, Matt Kenseth could have the opposite fate.  Never invest too much in today's hot driver he could be tomorrows turkey. Perpetual favorites like Mark Martin, Richard Petty, Dale Earnhardt, Dale Earnhardt Jr. Jimmie Johnson, Tony Stewart, etc... are exceptions and can almost always be expected to do well.
  • Listed Value - Guides such as Beckett and Diecast Diegest are full of good information but are not always easy to follow and sometimes are way off on values.  Subscriptions to these guides are a good investment but always take the values stated with a grain of salt.  If you are selling on eBay, the Beckett and Diecast Diegest guides are almost never correct for values so you should use more appropriate research such as Terapeak or Hammertap to determine your values.

Muscle Car and Other Diecast

118 Highway 61 1969 Chevy Camaro SS396 Green 50393
118 Highway 61 1969 Chevy Camaro SS396 Green 50393
Paypal   US $28.87
Lane 1 18 1965 Chevelle Z 16 Chevy Yellow w Black Int
Lane 1 18 1965 Chevelle Z 16 Chevy Yellow w Black Int
Paypal   US $64.95
GMP 118 1967 Ford Fairlane GT Yellow Exact Detail New
GMP 118 1967 Ford Fairlane GT Yellow Exact Detail New
Paypal   US $98.95
Lane 1 18 1970 Olds 442 INDY Oldsmobile Convertible
Lane 1 18 1970 Olds 442 INDY Oldsmobile Convertible
Paypal   US $129.95
Lane 1 18 1972 Oldsmobile Hurst 442 Linda Vaughn Olds
Lane 1 18 1972 Oldsmobile Hurst 442 Linda Vaughn Olds
Paypal   US $359.95
GMP 112 1964 Shelby Cobra 289 Street Car Red New
GMP 112 1964 Shelby Cobra 289 Street Car Red New
Paypal   US $274.95
118 EXACT DETAIL 1967 MUSTANG SHELBY GT500 CANDYAPPLE
118 EXACT DETAIL 1967 MUSTANG SHELBY GT500 CANDYAPPLE
Paypal   US $109.99
118 Highway 61 1971 Plymouth Barracuda Gran Coupe 383
118 Highway 61 1971 Plymouth Barracuda Gran Coupe 383
Paypal   US $37.00
118 Highway 61 1970 Plymouth Barracuda Gran Coupe Red
118 Highway 61 1970 Plymouth Barracuda Gran Coupe Red
Paypal   US $26.67
1967 CAMARO SS RED HOT ROD MAGAZINE 118 LANE EXACT
1967 CAMARO SS RED HOT ROD MAGAZINE 118 LANE EXACT
Paypal   US $84.99
   1

If NASCAR diecast is attractive to you then by all means collect NASCAR.  But if the history of the automobile is of any interest you should look into the amazing diecasts available in non-NASCAR classifications.  Almost every significant car in history is available as a diecast from some very fine manufacturers.  From the Model T Ford and original Benz to a Studebaker Truck or a 1953 Buick Skylark (The real first American Sports Car), almost any car or truck can be found in diecast.

Premium Manufacturers

  • Franklin Mint - Fine, limited edition diecast cars, trucks, and even NASCAR greats.  Franklin Mint makes all kinds of Diecast collectibles including aviation, maritime, and motorcycle pieces. Difficult to find values priced attractive enough to be considered worthy of re-sale.
  • Lane - Exact Detail - Makers of fine American musclecars and classics. Incredible detail in limited editions with values that can be worthy of investment.
  • GMP - Georgia Marketing Promotions - These are diecasts made by ERTL for GMP and are fine diecasts.
  • Ertl - Makers of all types of diecast collectables. The 1/18 scale automobiles marketed under the name American Muscle usually carry the highest resale value.


There are dozens of manufacturers of these types of diecasts.  You must learn what will sell and when you start out collecting stick with the most popular names with the most popular models.  A 1967 Shelby Cobra GT500 will sell much faster than a 1962 Ford Falcon no matter the manufacturer of the respective diecasts.

Liberty Classics 1930s Model A Tanker Clark Coin Bank
Liberty Classics 1930s Model A Tanker Clark Coin Bank
Paypal   US $25.95
Franklin Mint 1993 Corvette B11UQ63 Black Convertible
Franklin Mint 1993 Corvette B11UQ63 Black Convertible
Paypal   US $54.00
Franklin Mint Elvis Presleys 1965 Shelby Cobra 427 S C
Franklin Mint Elvis Presleys 1965 Shelby Cobra 427 S C
Paypal   US $135.00
Franklin Mint 1997 Corvette Convertable B11WW95 Red
Franklin Mint 1997 Corvette Convertable B11WW95 Red
Paypal   US $54.00
Liberty Classics Trustworthy Hardware 1940 Ford Pickup
Liberty Classics Trustworthy Hardware 1940 Ford Pickup
Paypal   US $25.95
Franklin Mint 124 1911 Rolls Royce Tourer AMAZING
Franklin Mint 124 1911 Rolls Royce Tourer AMAZING
Paypal   US $175.00
1969 Pontiac GTO Judge Franklin Mint 143 MIB NR
1969 Pontiac GTO Judge Franklin Mint 143 MIB NR
Paypal   US $40.40
FRANKLIN MINT 1968 CORVETTE T TOP
FRANKLIN MINT 1968 CORVETTE T TOP
Paypal   US $35.00
Franklin Mint 1955 Chevrolet Bel Air Fire Cheif Special
Franklin Mint 1955 Chevrolet Bel Air Fire Cheif Special
Paypal   US $49.00
Franklin Mint 1913 Ford Model T Pickup B11E255
Franklin Mint 1913 Ford Model T Pickup B11E255
Paypal   US $89.99
   1

Care should be taken when selling these types of diecasts to photograph them completely. Most buyers are collectors and know what they are buying, but there are new collectors coming into the hobby every day.  Show the new collector the extraordinary detail of these diecasts (spark plug wires, real suspension with springs and shocks, rotating driveshafts, etc.).

NASCAR Diecast


Manufacturers -

  • Action - # 1 in the industry. Many levels of cars in multiple scales sold through multiple outlets.  Action owns numerous other manufacturers and they are the king of NASCAR diecast.  Action owns - Revell, RCCA, Brookfield and Winners Circle.  Winners Circle is the low end line sold via big box discount retailers.  The top of the line is the RCCA Elite line of Action Diecast. RCCA Elite has the highest detail available in a 1/24 scale diecast.
  • Team Caliber - Preferred, Pit Stop and Owners series.  Some consider the Team Caliber Owners series as the most detailed and highest quality diecast in the business. Unfortunately they do not always sell as well as Action or Action Elite.  The quality is very high but the name is not as well known or as widely distributed.  Preferred series is comparable to standard Action diecast collectibles and is almost always a numbered limited edition. Pit Stop is comparable to Winner's Circle cars.
  • Franklin Mint - Best Quality - limited availability.  Mostly limited editions of NASCAR greats like Richard Petty.

NASCAR Collectibles - Scales & Terms

Scale

DENNIS SETZER 59 ALLIANCE LUMINA AMERICAN MUSCLE 1 18
DENNIS SETZER 59 ALLIANCE LUMINA AMERICAN MUSCLE 1 18
Paypal   US $24.99
RANDY BELMONT 95 OLD MILWAUKEE AMERICAN MUSCLE 1 18
RANDY BELMONT 95 OLD MILWAUKEE AMERICAN MUSCLE 1 18
Paypal   US $24.99
06 Ryan Newman 12 Alltel Tribute Nascar Hood $2499NEW
06 Ryan Newman 12 Alltel Tribute Nascar Hood $2499NEW
Paypal   US $24.99
Dale Earnhardt Army 30
Dale Earnhardt Army 30
Paypal   US $36.90
2000 Dale Earnhardt 3 Peter Max Hauler 1 64 NIB LE
2000 Dale Earnhardt 3 Peter Max Hauler 1 64 NIB LE
Paypal   US $34.79
JEFF GORDON JIMMIE JOHNSON DIECAST COLLECTION ACTION
JEFF GORDON JIMMIE JOHNSON DIECAST COLLECTION ACTION
Paypal   US $200.00
16 DR DIECAST LUMINA 1 18 AMERICAN MUSCLE
16 DR DIECAST LUMINA 1 18 AMERICAN MUSCLE
Paypal   US $24.99
124 NISSAN FABULOUS VARIOUS VIP ALPHARD MS AS
124 NISSAN FABULOUS VARIOUS VIP ALPHARD MS AS
Paypal   US $29.11
2002 Dale Earnhardt Jr 3 Nilla Wafer Nutter Butter NIB
2002 Dale Earnhardt Jr 3 Nilla Wafer Nutter Butter NIB
Paypal   US $49.99
2003 Dale Earnhardt Jr 8 MLB All Star Game Chicago NIB
2003 Dale Earnhardt Jr 8 MLB All Star Game Chicago NIB
Paypal   US $59.99
   1
  • 1/64 = Similar to a matchbox or hot wheels type of car.  Fun to collect and fine for new collectors but do not expect to make a living buying and selling 1/64 scale cars
  • 1/32 = Limited editions - easy to store and some very rare gold plated versions available.  Nice size for a personal collection.
  • 1/24 = Most popular size - must have for the seller of diecast cars. Easy to sell, easy to ship and the best compromise bewteen size and detail for collectors.
  • 1/18 = More detail than any smaller size.  More difficult to store and ship, older cars extremely heavy. Be careful on your shipping charges on these.  1/18 scale Action diecasts have more detail than 1/24 RCCA Action Elite.
  • 1/10 = Very rare - very large - very detailed - very expensive - more likely found from Franklin Mint or other manufacturers.

Terms

  • CW = Clear Window - The interior of the car is in full view with all of the details. Driver seat, steering wheel, gear shift, air vents, roll bars etc are all available to the viewer in explicit detail.
  • Bank = A car with a coin slot - from the origins of diecast collectibles. Banks were manufactured to increase the uniqueness of a NASCAR diecast before NASCAR was as popular as it is today.  The original banks were black window and some of them are very rare indeed.  In recent years only clear window banks have been produced in very low numbers. These banks would seem to have a high value but inversely they seem to not carry a lot of regard with collectors.  IF you find a black window bank look twice at the value, otherwise it is a loss leader in most instances.
  • BW = Black Window- As described above.
  • HO = Hood Opens - reveals detail of engine and drive train.
  • TO = Trunk Opens - reveals details in rear of car - fuels cell etc.
  • Hauler = a replica of a 18 wheel truck which the teams use to transport race cars and equipment to the various tracks. There are serious collectors of only haulers so do not discount this line of diecast.
  • Pit Wagon = Team Tool Box - replica of the tool box used in the pits.
  • Helmet = replica of a driver helmet

Keep in mind that diecasts in your collection can always find a home with someone else. You may have to list them in an eBay store to find a particular buyer who values your specific diecast or re- list it on multiple occasions but there is always someone on eBay who will buy what you have available.  Keep in mind that your price must be appropriate to give the new buyer value for their purchase.

Conclusion

Diecast collection is fun and rewarding

Diecast selling is challenging and even more rewarding.

Start small and work way into the business of selling diecast.  It is a business that can be easily run from your home garage.  It does not take much effort in customer service to make yourself stand out in the eBay marketplace.  Take the best photos, ship ASAP and describe your product in every detail and you will earn a loyal following of buyers.  If diecast buyers are anything, they are loyal if you are honest and forthright. Always take care of your customers and they will take care of you.

SET OF 3 124 SCALE DIE CAST CRAFTSMEN TRUCK SERIES
SET OF 3 124 SCALE DIE CAST CRAFTSMEN TRUCK SERIES
Paypal   US $25.00
Jeff Gordon 24 1997 Monte Carlo Racecar
Jeff Gordon 24 1997 Monte Carlo Racecar
Paypal   US $24.95
Dale Earnhardt Sr 2000 Tasmanian Devil 118Nascar
Dale Earnhardt Sr 2000 Tasmanian Devil 118Nascar
Paypal   US $21.51
2001 Dale Earnhardt C5R Corvette Daytona 1 18 Ltd Ed
2001 Dale Earnhardt C5R Corvette Daytona 1 18 Ltd Ed
Paypal   US $26.00
VERY RARE DALE EARNHARDT SR WHEATIES 1 24 FREE 1 64
VERY RARE DALE EARNHARDT SR WHEATIES 1 24 FREE 1 64
Paypal   US $39.99
VERY RARE DALE EARNHARDT SR BASS PRO SHOPS 1 24CARDS
VERY RARE DALE EARNHARDT SR BASS PRO SHOPS 1 24CARDS
Paypal   US $39.99
RYAN NEWMAN signed 2010 US ARMY 1 24 ACTION
RYAN NEWMAN signed 2010 US ARMY 1 24 ACTION
Paypal   US $80.00
JOEY LOGANO signed 2009 NEW HAMPSIRE WIN 1 24 ACTION
JOEY LOGANO signed 2009 NEW HAMPSIRE WIN 1 24 ACTION
Paypal   US $80.00
2002 BOBBY LABONTE 18 INTERSTATE LETS ROLL 164 y52
2002 BOBBY LABONTE 18 INTERSTATE LETS ROLL 164 y52
Paypal   US $20.79
Lot of 2 2003 Dale Earnhardt 1 24 Scale
Lot of 2 2003 Dale Earnhardt 1 24 Scale
Paypal   US $35.00
   1

Good luck in your new endeavor, buying and selling is fun and challenging and try to remember you will not make a profit on every item, but you will enjoy seeing them come and go out the door. You will gain confidence as you increase sales, your sales will increase with your confidence.

Enjoy the business of collecting and collecting as a business!

Comments

Trying to find out what a Michael Waltrip season 1997 1/24 scale Revell Citco #21 Dalmation car is worth. Please comment back to me at me buhlk@cox.net

 

Leave a Comment

« Bill Elliott – Awesome Bill From Dawsonville – A Popular NASCAR Legend | Home | AUTOGRAPHED Michael Waltrip #15 NAPA / Nila Wafers Monte Carlo Elite by: Action »